From Cyberculture to Cultural Industries
Hualien Cultural & Creative Industries Park, Taiwan - Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0
In today’s digital abundance, shaped by the network society, the virtual hungers for the real. Cyberculture’s manifestations increasingly spill beyond their binary borders, gradually establishing themselves as levers of a physical visibility that fuels social intervention, creativity, and protest. The citizen - now in an emancipated, postmodern version, networked through the reconfiguration of space and time - interacts with peers and drives knowledge networks that assert themselves ever more forcefully in the public sphere.
In the past, through every variety of media, the world has witnessed popular revolutions. From the failed attempt at revolution in Iran - which turned social media into the mythologized vehicle of the vox populi - to the popular uprisings in Tunisia and Egypt, whose outcomes are already known, interaction among citizens of different societies has set off a real earthquake in the traditional forms of relationship between individuals, now legitimized by their possession of control mechanisms once unthinkable. One might question the degree of empowerment this new social reality actually represents. Even so, everyone will acknowledge that, despite the more skeptical voices regarding a truly free and independent public opinion, nothing will be the same once the knowledge society takes hold across most of the Western or Westernized world.
But it is not only the political dimension that is being reorganized. In The Rise of the Creative Class, Richard Florida describes the emergence of three creative dimensions, themselves not unrelated to the birth of the network society: the creative ethos, the creative economy, and the creative class. This new creative class asserts itself through technology, culture, and the economy, without forgoing the genuinely global dimension that - more than a mere phenomenon - takes shape as a way of acting and thinking. We are seeing the emergence of a new pole that brings together, under a single concept, a high level of education and substantial human capital. Creative industries exploit intellectual property, generating economic dynamics grounded in this emerging creative thinking, inseparable from the concept of sharing. Can creative industries benefit from genuinely cosmopolitan cooperation in ways that drive local development? This text will attempt to answer this and other related questions.
THE BIRTH OF CYBERSPACE
In recent years we have witnessed the emergence of new virtual media spaces whose location in space and time is not clearly defined. Speculating about these new spaces of consumption, leisure, and communication, which society’s digital revolution has opened up to us, allows one to say almost anything and its opposite: “(…) immense progress or disastrous regression, the rise of the democratic individual or the alienation of civic consciousness, a powerful instrument of acculturation or a giant lobotomizing machine” (Nora, 1995, p. 263). We should not underestimate the effects of such major innovations. And yet, are technological factors not more a conditioning influence than a determining one in the life of civilizations? To treat technique as a conditioning factor is to say that certain cultural or social choices could not be conceived without its presence - not that we are its hostages or wholly determined by it (Lévy, 2000). While it is true that the digital revolution should be seen as a conditioning force, it is equally true that it is increasingly replacing the traditional functions of acculturation, civic participation, and social interaction. This new phenomenon has become decisive in the evolution of societies, to the point that it can no longer be considered a mere instrumental process, but rather a revolution capable of generating synergies and transforming society.
We are thus witnessing the birth of a new sociocultural paradigm, one that generates new cultural identities on the basis of major technological development and the acceleration of reality. With the new communication and information technologies comes a shift in how we conceive of territory. The reconfiguration of time and space produces “(…) human relations that are less stable and identity-defining and more mutable and networked; less hierarchical and more egalitarian and enriching” (Bauman, as cited in Tortosa, 2008, p. 260). Humanity now faces a shared destiny that seems to be emerging as never before: electronic connectivity. The computer emerges as the machine driving this radical change:
The computerization of society brings about cultural transformations that gradually manifest in individual behavior. Virtual communities alter the symbolic system in its role as an instrument of communication between people and social groups. This new sociocultural reconfiguration opens space for what Pierre Lévy calls Cyberspace. This new medium of communication, arising from the worldwide interconnection of computers, encompasses not only the global infrastructure of digital communication but also the universe of information it houses and the human beings who navigate and feed that universe (Silva, 2007). Cyberspace represents an advanced - though still developing - stage of social self-organization, one that will eventually give rise to collective intelligence. According to Pierre Lévy, this new space of knowledge (knowledge and the continuous production of subjectivity) constitutes the Fourth Anthropological Space (Earth, Territory, Social Group, and Cyberspace).
As cyberspace grows, a set of techniques - both material and intellectual - develops alongside it, along with practices, attitudes, modes of thought, and values: Cyberculture (Silva, 2007). This set of sociocultural phenomena occurs within cyberspace or is related to it. Virtual communities thus form around shared interests, whether among individuals or organizations, and may take various forms of expression: “Understanding cyberspace requires that it not be seen as an object in the strict sense of the term, but rather as a space inhabited by personas that constitute localities and territorialities” (Silva, 2007, p. 208). Richard MacKinnon¹ defines personas as identities that people construct within cyberspace. The virtuality that seems to underlie this subjective construction - usually associated with a kind of non-reality - is not, in fact, a particularly useful way of thinking about cyberspace. The virtual is not opposed to the real. It complements and transforms it, since it subverts the spatiotemporal limitations the real presents. We are faced, then, with a “level” of reality “(…) substantially distinct and different from the others, within which peculiar phenomena unfold and must be approached with a suitably developed or adapted theoretical framework” (Silva, 2007, p. 209). This anthropology of cyberspace is thus regarded as one more facet of other realities. The new concept of cyberanthropology resides in network space and constitutes a social reality made up of a set of coordinated activities, built by multiple interlocutors dispersed across physical space. A multiplicity of subjects converges toward activities aimed at reaching a shared meaning:
At first glance, the term virtual community might suggest a community that exists only in cyberspace. On a broader reading, however, it implies a new form of connection that comes to exist within - or between - communities in the real geosocial space, linking and extending them, and even bringing real communities into contact with one another. In this sense, the culture of computer-mediated networks offers an analogy for the world itself: “(…) a place where a topographic space (interface) is built, with locations (sites) and routes (paths) to be traveled until one reaches a destination” (Silva, 2007, p. 211).
In light of this fourth anthropological dimension - or space - we may ask whether a new social fabric is emerging, one equipped with more diverse creative mechanisms, enriched by the sharing of information on a global scale. If cyberculture becomes the long-sought engine of a new society - one that draws on the virtual to bring about, more swiftly and instantaneously, cultural changes that tend toward the dissolution of an elitist culture - can creativity then be within everyone’s reach?
CYBERCULTURE AND THE CREATIVE PROCESS
There is a shared, consensual feeling that emerges from all the technological revolutions of recent decades: a sense of innovation. This cause-and-effect relationship, set in motion by the vast melting pot the world has become, should take hold within the public sphere - or at least, that is the hope. Can cyberculture, as a constellation of relational networks, awaken an emergence of new values, a sense of multiple belonging capable of affecting the economic and social fabric of the conventional city?
Florida’s creative class encompasses science and engineering, architecture and design, education and the arts, music and entertainment (Florida, 2002). The creative class is therefore multidisciplinary, networked, and flexible. The environment best suited to its emergence is one that makes room for creativity grounded in difference and merit. This requires three fundamental spheres: technology, talent, and tolerance. Yet, according to Florida, major change comes not only through innovation but also through the mass movement of people (Florida, 2010). Talent must therefore circulate between places in order to foster potential creative scenarios. This postulated circulation highlights the importance - beyond what has already been mentioned - of a fourth sphere that proves essential to this discussion: territory. The city emerges as the privileged space for the proliferation of creativity, with creative industries tasked with bringing it to fruition - something inseparable from a pressing media agenda that demands public attention, making that space an increasingly valuable one within a society built on the information paradigm.
Mobility thus emerges as a premise of the utmost importance for the creative recycling of cities. How can cyberculture foster a mobility transferable from the physical to the virtual realm without losing its effectiveness? As Rheingold puts it, it is now virtual communities that form the webs of personal relationships grounded in shared interests, webs in which creativity plays a decisive role. Richard Florida stresses the decisive role of new technologies: “At the same time, ideas can travel the world almost instantaneously along digital highways […] A single keystroke can trigger the exchange of insights and creativity between societies, and this singular phenomenon has revolutionized the way we live” (Florida, 2010, p. 156 [our translation]).
THE EMERGENCE OF THE CYBERCITY
There is an implicit advantage in the economic model Florida describes, one built on a strong - and therefore immaterial - creative component: a wager on harnessing local resources through creative processes of transformation. The world necessarily becomes flat. We live through “(…) the dynamizing force of the Globalization 3.0 era - the force that gives it its unique character - [which] is the newly discovered possibility for individuals to collaborate and compete globally” (Friedman, 2010, pp. 19–20). The birth of the cybercity runs deeply parallel to this flattened world we now inhabit, driving the convergence between new digital communication and information technologies and the classical urban structure where innovation is meant to take place: thus emerges a “second artificial order.” This new order includes the new telematic networks and the technologies derived from them, such as the Internet, wireless networks, mobile communication systems, and other cybernetic possibilities that profoundly alter social dynamics. Even so, these networks remain dependent on the material substance of urban infrastructure.² They share space with transportation, sanitation, energy, and conventional communication networks, taking on a hybrid status that fuses the physical and the imaginary (Westwood & Williams, 1997). Zygmunt Bauman³ would name this new order “liquid modernity” (Bauman, 2000).
We may then think - or hope - that within cybercities, spaces can be complementary, with physical space remaining the more usual form in which a society exists. To this ongoing debate, we would add the significant influence that the use of electronic devices has in promoting demonstrations in physical space. Cases of political protest mobilized through the network, real-world meetings between citizens fostered by chat rooms or virtual communities, online purchases that set off flows of goods circulating through road, rail, and air networks - all are clear signs of the synergies established between virtual space and the space of place. We should take advantage of a new rhizomatic structure that allows for horizontality and the free flow of information, which makes the cybercity a contemporary city, equipped with a powerful range of communication networks, yet one that still relies on major centers as radiating hubs of innovation and concentrators of capital and labor. These networks have encouraged the growth of communities connected by shared interests, fostering mutual enrichment and, in turn, a greater capacity for creativity.
A NEW ECONOMIC PARADIGM
In industrial societies, the degree of inclusion was measured by the possession of material resources. In the information society, it is intellectual resources that speak loudest in this regard. This raises one of the questions implicit earlier on: the creative class requires independent judgment and a high level of education (Florida, 2002). It is within this new configuration - in which sharing decisively takes the key place in the entire socioeconomic structure - that cyberculture establishes itself as indispensable to raising levels of the key indicator of twenty-first-century competitiveness: innovation. In this context, cyberculture will contribute to a culture of creativity, opening the door to new ways of gauging non-technological creativity and analyzing the process of entrepreneurial creativity within the creative and cultural sector.
In the new economic geography, new forms of consumption benefit from this intensive exchange of ideas and discussions circulating through the Knowledge Society. This new reality - grounded in speed, customization, and intangible value, with ever-shorter product life cycles, especially in the information and communication technology sector - calls for a strong innovative component: the market demands innovation just as much as technical competence. If innovation requires investment in research and development (R&D) labs, these can exist within a telematic network and later be transferred to the market. Through the reconfiguration of space and time, collaboration within network-based communication can benefit from significant cost-sharing while simultaneously introducing new forms of industrial organization that value freedom, autonomy, and divergent thinking. We are thus placed, definitively, within the domain of the Creative Industries.
If we take a few minutes to reflect on the concept of goods in postmodernity - or in the post-material society - we find that today it is expressive content (aesthetic, symbolic, or social) that determines an industry’s success. Experience, as a new kind of economic output, thus makes clear the importance of virtual space as a source of product validation: the product is validated by the community and by social networks. As Jean Baudrillard notes, technology is no longer capable of conveying the value of an object on its own (Baudrillard, 2010). There is a non-rational dimension to consumer needs, one that causes an object to take on meaning correlated with its cultural environment or with social aspirations.
We return to Florida to consider the new dimension of symbolic value. Artists, advertisers, designers, marketers, media, and culture all converge around this new dimension. It is through creativity that the new economy develops, generating massive consumer interest. Companies increasingly turn to the services of trendspotters, anthropologists, sociologists, and psychologists. Creative functions within companies take on critical importance, supported by fields such as design, marketing, advertising, and communications. This new reality makes clear that the creative class is indispensable to the new economy, reinforcing the importance of a new, globally oriented culture in shaping it: cyberculture.
CONCLUSION
There is a new form of economy in contemporary life: the sharing economy. The production of wealth ceases to be society’s ultimate goal, giving way instead to the creation of social bonds. Although this observation may risk oversimplifying matters, the truth is that money is no longer the primary currency of exchange in certain relationships. We may well be witnessing the shift from a property-based regime to an access-based one. Given growing concerns about sustainability, the accumulation of goods is losing its meaning. Economist Jeremy Rifkin is not far from the truth when he says that the market now lives in networks (Rifkin, 2001). Industrial production is being replaced by cultural production grounded in the marketing of cultural experiences.
This new hyper-capitalism is shaped by tourism, entertainment, theme parks, fashion, wellness, sports, cultural products, and, not least, the Internet. In the age of access, we are witnessing the commodification of entertainment and the marketing of cultural resources. The Internet, with its billions of users, is the “mecca” of the access and sharing economy. The sharing of interests now takes place on Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube. Out of this new sense of belonging to groups, industry will need to find new forms of interaction, opening up space for culturally grounded creativity as the core of the new paradigm.
If Rifkin’s prediction is correct, and the “age of access” does translate into the commodification of entertainment, then it is worth looking to the creative sector for inspiration. In “Globalization as Culture,” it is culture itself that supplies the model for the production of goods. It is the creative class, working within the Creative Industries, that tends to possess a well-developed understanding of the importance of signs, symbols, emotions, and aesthetic sensibility. The capacity to build communities is an essential feature of the new economy - a capacity that depends heavily on creativity and culture.
And where better to look for creatives imbued with this new entrepreneurial spirit than in cyberculture itself?
Footnotes
- Richard C. MacKinnon is a professor at the University of Texas at Austin, whose work focuses on the study of communities and computer-mediated communication.
- The space of flows is characterized by the physical spaces made up of cables, servers, routers, hubs, and other infrastructure necessary for the flow of communications.
- Zygmunt Bauman is a sociologist, born in 1925 in the city of Poznań, Poland. His work centers on the relationship between modernity and the Holocaust, as well as on postmodernity. (Cf. Wikipedia [online]. Accessed May 22, 2010, at: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zygmunt_Bauman.)
Bibliography
BAUDRILLARD, J. (2010). A Sociedade de Consumo. Lisboa: Edições 70.
BAUMAN, Z. (2000). Liquid Modernity. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing Ltd.
FLORIDA, R. (2002). The Rise of the Creative Class. New York: Basic Books.
FLORIDA, R. (2010). The Great Reset. New York: Harper.
FRIEDMAN, T. L. (2010). O Mundo é Plano. Lisboa: Actual Editora.
LÉVY, P. (2000). Cibercultura. Lisboa: Instituto Piaget.
NORA, D. (1995). Os Conquistadores do Ciberespaço. Lisboa: Terramar.
SILVA, A. M. P. da. (2007). Ciberantropologia: o estudo das comunidades virtuais. In J. S. RIBEIRO & S. BAIRON (org.), Antropologia Visual e Hipermedia, (pp. 207–218). Porto: Edições Afrontamento.
RIFKIN, J. (2001). A Era do Acesso. A Revolução da Nova Economia. Lisboa: Editorial Presença.
TORTOSA, V. (2008). Sujetos mutantes: nuevas identidades en la cultura. In D. R. Lopez & A. S. Cabrerizo (ed.), Literaturas del texto al hipermedia, (pp. 257–272). Barcelona: Anthropos.
WESTWOOD, S. & WILLIAMS, J. (1997). Imagining Cities. Scripts, signs, memory. London: Routledge.