Paulo Pinto

/notes ✎ Article

Android or Human?

Android or Human? Photo: AI

The dialectical relationship between reality and mental construction, viewed through a constructivist-cognitive lens, shapes the processes of learning and ontological awareness, revealing the world to us in a manner that is subjectively Kantian. The traditional epistemological question of the object of knowledge finds a concrete answer here: reality can be understood as the result of a “passive” reproduction, the formula for which lies in the a posteriori validation of a mathematical algorithm that constrains individual autonomy. The advent of technology and rationality was expected to set humankind on a path toward the collective interest, by means of a technical discourse capable of solving every problem.

If we think of the relationships arising from networked communication as a form of cybernetic feedback - one in which linear causality breaks down and a causal loop forms, whereby A acts on B, which in turn acts on A - we may be tempted to embrace the analogy between machine behavior and human behavior, and call ourselves Androids. Experience would then become the determining factor in this process, functioning like a computerized check digit: it would cast the rational construction of reality as the product of individual cognitive processes rather than the outcome of social and historical experience (Sampson, 1981).

This view lends itself readily to the thesis that new technologies have an alienating, inhibiting effect on individuals - implying that to understand machine behavior is to understand ourselves. Seen from another angle, though, the degree of indeterminacy built into the material makeup of communication infrastructures leaves room to conceive of this relationship in reverse: “(…) it is now possible to study our artificial environment - how it behaves, why it behaves as it does, and what it seeks to do - by analogy with what we know about ourselves” (Dick, 2006, p. 31).

Seen optimistically, these horizontal flows of information can be tied to a strong anthropological dimension - one that recognizes each individual’s humanity and the central role communication plays in building social identity through feedback: “To understand himself, man needs to be understood by his fellow human beings. To be understood by others, he must understand them” (Hora, as cited in Watzlawick, 1991, p. 13).

Above all, this dialogical need should be an internal process, one that consolidates each cybercitizen’s idiosyncrasies. If it is, we will be contributing not to a syncretism synonymous with the reification of human beings, but to a constellation of authenticity and mutual enrichment: “(…) what defines an android and a human being is not their origin - mechanical or organic - but their actions, whether rigid or empathetic, toward others. An android can act humanely just as much as a human being […] can behave like an android” (Dick, 2006, pp. 13–14).

Bibliography

Dick, P. K. (2006). O andróide e o humano. Lisboa: Vega.

Sampson, E. (1981). Cognitive psychology as ideology. American Psychologist, 36, 30-43.

Watzlawick, P. (1991). A realidade é real?. Lisboa: Relógio D’Água.