Blade Runner - The Nostalgia of the Future
San Diego Comic-Con 2007 day 3. Photo by Jason Scragz, CC BY 2.0.
In 1968, Philip K. Dick, an American writer born in Chicago in 1928, wrote a work that would become one of the icons of science fiction literature and a cult object among lovers of the genre. The work, titled Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?, inspired the 1982 film directed by Ridley Scott: Blade Runner. The film itself, a gradual success, was adapted into several book editions, for example the Portuguese edition Blade Runner Perigo Iminente, №43 in the Europa-América pocket science fiction series.
Philip K. Dick belongs to a somewhat disregarded literary current that helped establish a body of literature known as cyberpunk, which includes names like William Gibson, whose emblematic work Neuromancer is recognized as a precursor of the movement. This subcategory of science fiction, which includes Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?, casts a fatalistic, dystopian look at the interaction between technology and humanity, establishing a cause/effect relationship in the social stew: humanity’s excessive dependence on machines and the reification of the individual.
From this movement arises a nihilistic viewpoint, a dystopian cyberpunk culture moving toward a dark, sinister world in which machines aim to replace humans. A seemingly irreconcilable field is born between technoscience and religion, between positivist and metaphysical worldviews, accentuating the dualistic character of Western society that - since Descartes - has presented the figure of an evil demon. A monster that seems necessary for reconciliation between humans, Nature, and Artifice.
Within this organic totality of the human, we are characterized by complexity and contradiction. We live in the megapolis heading for the “black future” and decline. We become aware of the social, cultural, and scientific complexity of our times’ landscapes. But cyberpunk art is also moral art, concerned with imperfections, failures, and dubious ethical choices.
Understanding Dick’s literature and, subsequently, the film Blade Runner requires knowing a bit about the life of a writer who lived a troubled life - tormented by the death of his twin sister a few days (40) after birth - which became an obsession through his adult years, creating a permanent spiritual relationship with her. Philip K. Dick early on was influenced by fantastic literature and pulp magazines such as Unknown and Astounding.
He attended university for only one year and was largely self-taught. The need to earn a living forced him to write constantly. He relied on amphetamines and LSD, dramatically increasing his literary output but paying the price with serious physical and emotional problems.
A mystical vision changed his life: a phenomenon he never explained that made him feel he lived two eras simultaneously - the past (the Roman Empire era) and the present. This fact, which drove him to write the endless Exegesis, is important for understanding Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?. His deep love for classical music - much of the action takes place in an opera house - reveals a bridge to the past, perhaps a bridge to his sister. Music often appears as that spiritual connection to someone lost. Curiously, Dick embraces the past and future as a great ruin consuming him, contributing to an esoteric, enigmatic work full of symbolism.
Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? is a dramatic work, a reflection on the metamorphosis of the individual in a society moving toward a purely technological outcome - a society increasingly hybrid. This diversity, urgent to highlight and denounce, manifests in cyberculture through post-human figures - cyborgs - which in Blade Runner (we assume Scott’s film as the embodiment of Dick’s legacy) are represented by the Nexus-6 replicants.
These cybercultural machines play the same role as bestiaries in the Middle Ages: they show the different, the exotic, the barbaric, to be better domesticated. But can we see Blade Runner’s future as a reinterpretation of the past, an urgency to justify all the evil left behind? Philip K. Dick seeks to differentiate authentic human beings from reflective machines (androids).
For him, an android is a metaphor for a physiologically human person with inhuman behavior. This obsession with madness cannot be separated from the experience of World War II. For Dick, the Nazis were a demented group - so emotionally defective that the word human did not apply to them. A phrase taken from SS diaries written in Poland deeply disturbed him:
We are kept awake at night by the cries of starving children. (Sammon, 1996: 16).
According to Dick, this madness would spread worldwide after WWII, making society more violent and unethical. To better understand the genesis of his book Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?, it should be noted that it was written in the middle of the Vietnam War.
BLADE RUNNER
The adaptation of the book into film took its first shape in 1969, a year after publication. Early interested parties included director Martin Scorsese and critic Jay Cocks, who were captivated by the visual and moral landscapes of the dystopian narrative. That interest, however, did not bear fruit.
Later, in 1974, Robert Jaffe wrote a script to adapt Dick’s book; after Dick read it, he reportedly called it “horrible.” After multiple attempts to improve the script with Dick’s help, the project stalled in 1977. That same year Hampton Fancher became involved and began work that would lead to the production and direction of Ridley Scott’s Blade Runner.
Although initially faithful to Dick’s book, Fancher’s early screenplay underwent numerous changes due to limited budgets and later ecological concerns.
I didn’t really create much of a world [in the initial screenplay]. You could have pretty much taken my first draft and put it on a (theatrical) stage. There weren’t many exterior scenes, there wasn’t much hardware. It was basically a small drama, [one originally projected to be] done for $9 million (Sammon, 1996: 36).
Notable changes include: San Francisco settings moving to Los Angeles; Iran (Deckard’s wife) becoming less important; and Rachel, Deckard’s love interest, gaining unusual prominence.
A DYSTOPIAN VISION
In this dystopian future, the “imminent danger” is replication. Everything becomes possible in a godless world: “If God is dead, then everything is possible,” Dostoevsky noted in Crime and Punishment; in Blade Runner, seemingly, “If everything is possible, then God is dead.” (Rosa, 2007: 7). Religiosity was always present in Philip K. Dick’s work. As Herlander Elias emphasizes, there is an implied danger in the film: technology capable of generating humans as genuine - or more genuine - than humans themselves, something unresolved in modernity, a negative yet romantic vision of the future.
God dies because Dr. Tyrell (the “father” of the androids) is killed by the leader of the replicants, Roy Batty. “God” names what is most transcendental (Cavalli, 2006). Roy Batty mediates between two consciences, reminding what humans once were in their search for God. Deckard is the postmodern subject, with identities that shift with time; Roy is the modern sociological subject, with an artificially defined, rational “I.”
One scientific project worth highlighting is the robot as an epistemological project (Elias, 2007). In his essay The Android and the Human, Dick says the difference between android and human is not origin - machine or organic - but action: rigid or empathetic toward others. An android can act humanly as much as a human can act like an android. What Blade Runner questions is that replicants are always replicas technologically superior to humans and aim to turn the world into a cyborg habitat. If what defines android and human are actions, could an android be more human than a human? Blade Runner does not resolve this ontological dilemma - replicants lack lifespan (Elias, 2007: 232); they do not have enough life time.
There are in the Universe cold and inhuman things that I have named ‘machines.’ Their behavior frightens me, especially when they imitate human behavior so well that I am left with the uncomfortable feeling that these things are trying to pass themselves off as human beings when they are not. (Dick, 2006: 77)
THE CITY OF MACHINES
In Blade Runner, Los Angeles is a city of machines - no longer equipped to function for humans. In 2019’s Los Angeles, machines replace humans. Technology has not solved human problems. How could human-like replicas solve problems their creators could not? This paradox encapsulates technology - or its use. Where are we heading with our machines of discontent? What machines can make us better humans: replicants, the Nexus-6, or some more evolved version? If replicants’ mission is to save the world, why do they live only four years?
The Los Angeles of the film is essentially a ‘place-machine,’ a cyborg territory simultaneously real and virtual, organic and mechanical, sane and schizoid - an arena of multiplicities, of constructions and deconstructions. (Elias, 2007: 234)
Descartes said we become masters and possessors of Nature; man becomes man by withdrawing from it. In Blade Runner everything ends in extermination: Nature is destroyed, and humans are destroyed by themselves through corrosive technique. Technique self-annihilates: Deckard (a machine) “kills” the replicant stripper (another machine). There is an inescapable predatory character that renders Blade Runner a remarkable transversal vision of human nature. We need monsters to feel more human, says José Gil (Elias, 2007 : 236).
Blade Runner takes place in an environment polluted by nuclear conflict, where radioactive dust is omnipresent, wiping out most animal life. Many humans die or become mentally incapacitated. The remaining population drifts toward sterility; some preserve virility and leave Earth for healthy planets. Rick Deckard, the police - the blade runner - is one unfortunate who remains in the dusty inferno. His job is to annihilate androids (“andys” in the book) trying to mix with humans. The androids have all human emotions except empathy. They were designed as weapons during nuclear conflict but were later reprogrammed as colonization workforce. Deckard must not let androids occupy humans’ place - he must annihilate them. In doing so, does he become an android?
Intriguingly, human beings in Blade Runner represent the post-industrial, nihilistic facet of society - loneliness and individualism that bury past claims. The struggle lost its militant character. Now androids embody the values of Enlightenment, rationality, and the fight for ideals. Humans are small narratives; androids are grand narratives. Androids symbolize romanticism; humans, decadence. This inversion of reification makes humans cold, desolate, unbelieving - and paradoxically, androids are made in their image.
This temporal inversion, breaking linearity, forces a serious reflection on our trajectory - already a concern in the early 1980s. The android appears the only way to rebuild, while the Deckards of this world annihilate that initiative. If technology means fatal progress - the basic premise of Blade Runner - how can androids, its children, symbolize hope? This inversion of logic makes Blade Runner an irresistible and delightful exercise in reflection: a narrative conflict placing resignation against the will to live. Signs of resignation are evident: Deckard’s alcoholism and J.F. Sebastian’s depression and loneliness.
A WORK WITHIN ANOTHER WORK
The music in Blade Runner is so devastatingly beautiful. Yet at the same time it is many other things. Tacky, ominous, haunting, sad. Vangelis did an extraordinary job; his score became a major character. - Rutger Hauer cited by Sammon, 1996:267)
Cinematically, an original score is part of post-production, where sequences and shots are decided and the musical score is chosen. Blade Runner’s post-production was scheduled for July 1981 with 34 weeks of work. As Sammon notes, movies are often made or broken in the editing room. Blade Runner was no exception. The complexity of the story required a score capable of conveying the psychological atmosphere of each scene. Ridley Scott used voice-over to explain certain scenes, but it was still criticized. Who could write a score worthy of such responsibility?
EVANGELOS O. PAPATHANASSIOU (VANGELIS)
Vangelis was not the initial obvious choice. Terry Rawlings, Blade Runner’s sound editor, said he never thought they would use Vangelis at first (Sammon, 1996). Many soundtracks were considered, including Jerry Goldsmith’s. Initial contact with Vangelis happened after his Oscar-winning Chariots of Fire score; upon seeing raw footage of Blade Runner he was moved and terrified — moved by the film’s beauty and terrified by the plausibly horrifying future it portrayed.
Evangelos O. Papathanassiou (Vangelis) was born in 1943 in Volos, Greece, and grew up in Athens. Self-taught and unable to read music, he composed his first piano piece at age four. In 1968, after Greece’s military dictatorship began, he moved to Paris and co-founded the band Aphrodite’s Child. The band’s popular song Rain and Tears, when reversed, reveals a coincidence with Roy Batty’s famous phrase “Tears in Rain.”
Vangelis’s reputation as an electronic composer and synthesizer master was well established. During the 1970s he composed music for French TV and films - Apocalypse Des Animaux and Opera Sauvage - and later moved to London, where he built his 24-track Nemo Studios. It was there he composed Blade Runner’s original score.
Vangelis’s first concern was to absorb the film’s “sense.” He spoke with Ridley Scott to gauge expectations and was immediately impressed, forming a strong emotional bond. He chose a tonal register that can be called “futuristic nostalgia”: a vertiginous blend of bold romanticism, ominous electronic noise, delicate celestial hues, gutter blues, and breath-taking melancholy.
Vangelis’s score became one of the most notable and sorrowful recordings for a sci-fi film. Between 1978 and 1982, he experimented with percussion mixed with synthesizers, integrating bells and chimes into Blade Runner’s sound palette.
Vangelis had to work with the wide, ambiguous space Scott had given him - a mixture of past and future, where the new and surprising stood opposed to what remained: the essence of nostalgia, what was once popular on Earth.
A LONG PROCESS
Normally film-score production is expensive and fast with many contributors. For Blade Runner, Vangelis composed, arranged, produced, and performed. He improvised basic melodies, recorded them to tape, and refined them by layering additional sounds and textures in a sculptural process. He often worked alone, with occasional visits from Scott or Terry Rawlings. His music had to be accepted as fitting for the film.
A major controversy around the original soundtrack concerned the long time it took to be released: the film credits in 1982 listed Polydor for the soundtrack, but the official album only appeared in 1994 - twelve years after the film’s release. Why the delay? Was Vangelis dissatisfied?
BOOTLEGS
The long gap between the film’s release and the official soundtrack opened room for numerous recordings and versions attempting to fill the void. First came a soundtrack without Vangelis - a soulless copy, a “replicant” soundtrack. Later, several incomplete or illegal releases appeared.
Between 1982 and 1994 various recordings surfaced.
Finally, in 1994 the soundtrack titled Blade Runner: Vangelis (Atlantic/Warner Music UK) - containing 12 tracks (some with film dialogue), including Love Theme, Tales of the Future, Memories of Green, and Blade Runner End Title - was officially released.
However, many others were missing. Two of them understandably so, since Harps of Ancient Temples was composed by Gail Laughton and Ogi no Mato is a traditional Japanese song.
Blade Runner (OST) 1994 Vangelis
Official Vangelis Score
Main Titles (3:42)
Blush Response (5:47)
Wait For Me (5:27)
Rachel’s Song (4:46)
Love Theme (4:56)
One More Kiss, Dear (3:58)
Blade Runner Blues (8:53)
Memoires of Green (5:05)
Tales of the Future (4:46)
Damask Rose (2:32)
Blade Runner (End Titles) (4:40)
Tears in Rain (3:00)
Where was Vangelis’s ominous two-note synth riff used in Tyrell’s death scene? (a clue that a 1993 bootleg was titled The Prodigal Son Brings Death).
Andrew Hoy explains it wasn’t due to any oversight by Vangelis. As a musician, Vangelis always cared about the quality of his products and the satisfaction of his listeners. In that sense, he did not include every theme from original film scores on his albums. The record was not a faithful reproduction of the film’s score. He did not see it as necessary to include reprises or sounds used only to emphasize a particular scene. On his albums, Vangelis always combined elements of the film score with new material.
Despite all these episodes and delays, despite some incompatibilities between script and original work, between Vangelis’s singular, perfectionist vision and Ridley Scott’s impatience, Philip K. Dick is unequivocal:
This is not like anything we have ever seen….It isn’t like anything that has ever been done (Philip K. Dick, author of Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?, after being shown footage of Blade Runner - from “They Did Sight Stimulation on My Brain,” by Gregg Rickman)
THE PLURALITY OF CULTURAL FORMS
A work of art is a product of its time and of its creators’ lived experience. Knowing Philip K. Dick’s motivations and history is essential to recognize important signs in his work. But each artwork also reflects the world in which it was produced: it is possible to emphasize the prevalence of representational forms, values, normative principles, and behavior models that show relative coherence within a historical society. Possibly for this reason Vangelis saw Dick’s dystopian vision as “his world,” perhaps because the dominant cultural system used its rules. The relationship between the works is not linear: each part influenced its successor, inspiring and provoking alterity. Each author added new interpretation and renewed vision, highlighting the creative act as interpretation. From Dick’s writing to Fancher’s script, from Scott’s shots to Vangelis’s music, the artwork’s polysemy appears in every second of image, word, and sound.
A CONTEMPORARY WORK
Concrete changes in cultural meaning systems occur slowly and can stem from external conditions or cultural creativity. A work of art can transform society, endure across time, disturb and affect, and foster permanent reflexivity. In this creative act bridges form for a language of its time, creating a lasting mass of the Zeitgeist. Intertextuality testifies to this.
Art, as technology of memory, legitimizes the lived past and inscribes a temporal horizon needing interpretation that joins work, author, and audience. In the poetic structure anticipating remembrance, social dynamics produced at a given time are concealed.
Thus, Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?, Blade Runner, and Vangelis’s original soundtrack must be analyzed together to understand the power relations they involve. Blade Runner remains current because its core concerns endure - almost forty years were not enough for a major cultural change to be evident, or perhaps the change occurred and we’ll recognize it much later.
THE CULT
Philip K. Dick
BladeZone: The Online Blade Runner Fan Club and Museum
BRMOVIE.com
BIBLIOGRAPHY
- Cavalli, V. (2006). A Linguagem Cinematográfica: Modelos Sociais e os Mitos Futuristas. Accessed May 1, 2012.
- Crespi, F. (1997). Manual de Sociologia da Cultura. Lisbon: Editorial Estampa.
- Dick, P. K. (2006). O andróide e o humano. Lisbon: Vega.
- Elias, H. (2007). Néon Digital. Um Discurso sobre os Ciberespaços. Accessed April 29, 2012.
- Rosa, J. M. (2007). Exegesis ou «Ele está no meio de nós». Revista FAMECOS, №34, 2007, pp. 7–13. Accessed April 29, 2012.
- Sammon, P. M. (1996). Future Noir. The Making of Blade Runner. New York: Itbooks.
- Tota, A. L. (2000). A Sociologia da Arte, Do Museu Tradicional à Arte Multimédia. Lisbon: Editorial Estampa.